How prop trading firms work and how to compare them
Proprietary trading firms let you trade a funded account in exchange for passing an evaluation and sharing profits. The model has grown rapidly, and so have the number of firms that change rules, delay payouts or shut down. Comparing prop firms is less about the size of the funded account and more about the fine print that decides whether you ever get paid.
Evaluation rules that decide your odds
Most firms run a one- or two-phase challenge with a profit target (commonly 8 to 10% in phase one), a maximum daily loss (typically 4 to 5%) and a maximum overall drawdown (8 to 12%). The critical details are whether drawdown is calculated on balance or equity, whether it trails your high-water mark, whether there are minimum trading days, and what counts as a rule breach. Rules on news trading, holding over weekends, copy trading and expert advisors vary widely and are the most common cause of disqualification.
Payouts, profit splits and scaling
Profit splits of 80 to 90% are standard, but the payout schedule, minimum payout, processing time and payment methods matter more. Check whether the first payout has a longer waiting period, whether there are consistency rules that cap any single day's share of profits, and how the firm has historically handled payout disputes. Scaling plans that increase your allocation are attractive but usually require sustained performance over several months.
Regulation, broker partners and firm stability
Prop firms are generally not regulated as brokers because you trade a demo or simulated account with the firm's own capital at risk. Some regulators, including in the EU, are reviewing the sector. Look at how long the firm has operated, which broker or liquidity partner it uses, whether it publishes verified payout data, and how it has responded when partners exited. Verified trader reviews on BrokerBazaar frequently flag sudden rule changes and account closures.
How BrokerBazaar rates prop firms
Each firm is scored on rule transparency, payout reliability, evaluation fairness, platform and instrument range, support and verified trader sentiment. Scores are editorial assessments by our research team based on published rules and trader evidence. They are not user ratings and not a recommendation. Sponsored placements are labelled and never change scores. Read our methodology and how we make money via the links below.
Frequently asked questions
Risk warning. Trading and investing involve risk and you may lose money. Nothing on this page is personal financial advice. Evaluation fees are non-refundable in most cases and the large majority of participants do not pass. Treat challenge fees as money at risk.
Independence. BrokerBazaar is not owned by any broker. We earn from subscriptions, listings, advertising and sponsorship, not from broker deposit or trading commissions. Paid placements are labelled and never influence our editorial scores. How we make money.